I am intrigued by @Zeek's Tier List (http://opforum.net/threads/one-piece-forum-tier-list.49672/), and want to get people's opinion on the "strongest" giants in a 1-1 against someone like Drake, Hawkins, Apoo, or Urogue. Even though Broggy and Dorry were fighting a "death match", from my perspective the two of them were sparring with real weapons (potential for death, but not putting forth their full effort). What makes me say this is that Oda had them perform the first bladed projectile (pretty sure Mihawk only uses regular sword strikes to cut Krieg's ship). In the manga, there are no visuals to the attack while the anime shows a blue/red projectile. I think Oda had the bladed projectiles in mind, but could not use it against the giant goldfish since it would cut the Going Merry (thus the shock wave effect that literally destroys the fish's flesh (remember it didn't cut a hole in the fish, it instantaneously disintegrated 1/4th to 1/5th of the fish). If Broggy and Dorry really wanted to kill each other, they would have been using big attacks like this from the start. So giants have the obvious advantage against most people in brute strength. The true powerhouses in One Piece can exceed the strength of giants. I agree with Zeek's list that there are many people with similar strength levels, but would win against Broggy/Dorry due to a speed advantage. Thus someone like Luffy in gear second (who's strength level is somewhat close to a giant) can win by delivering strong enough blows with a huge speed advantage. That brings us to the mid-tier level members of the Worst Generation. Some of them have abstract abilities that are major X-factors (Apoo and Hawkins), but none of them appear to have top tier speed. Urogue and Drake in his full T-Rex mode should at least be close to giant-level strength, but how fast are they? Sure they were completely dominated by Kizaru, but even Luffy's gear second was too slow against the speed of light. Personally, I don't think Urogue or Drake would win against Broggy or Dorry simply because they were not shown to be fast enough to evade attacks and move into range to land clean blows. Both have been implied to be strong enough to land winning blows, but both were even dominated in speed by the Pacifista (they are slower than the Mugiwaras). We don't have much on Hawkins' offensive capabilities when he activates his voodoo doll mode, but his ability to transfer damage to his sacrificial dolls would give him a chance to move into attack range. If he had the time to prepare enough dolls to survive a giant's attack, he has a chance to win. Apoo is the one I think that would be able to win the easiest since his ability allows for what appears to be pretty strong projectile attacks. Apoo was shown to be pretty quick in attempting to run away, so with the tactics of staying as far away as possible and launching barrages explosive music, he would win. I definitely don't think Apoo is the strongest/best fighter of this mid-tier (my vote would be Hawkins or Drake), but his skill set matches up against a giant the best.